Prime Element Creations Network: Home | Game Positive | ReviewTrax
Follow this site on
Best of: 2009 | 2010
E-Mail:
Password:
DarkStar One: Broken Alliance
Good Critical Reception
Good: 8
Excellent: 0
Poor: 1
Mediocre: 2
Platform:
Xbox 360
Genre:
Simulation
Developer:
Gaming Minds
ESRB:
Teen
Release:
July 20, 2010
Publisher:
Kalypso
Critic Reviews
The following reviews are used to calculate the overall reception for this game. All applicable scores are converted to our simplified rating system based on the specifics offered by each publication or the tone of each review. You can read more about how we do this here.
Dan Pearson
June 23, 2010 - Good - DarkStar One is undoubtedly a bit of a throwback. It's not the all-singing, all-dancing AAA space combat title which could still make a lot of console owners' days, but it does go an awfully long way to proving that a game of that calibre is eminently possible on consoles, as well as providing an entertaining diversion.
July 20, 2010 - Good - This adaptation to the gamepad works about as well as can be expected, considering there's nothing to sap the feeling of being in a spaceship cockpit quite so thoroughly as clutching a gamepad. But Darkstar One on the Xbox 360 isn't the way to relive the golden era of joysticks and keyboards. Those days are gone and you're on the couch now, taking what you can get.
July 19, 2010 - Good - With all its foibles, this space combat sim is a lighthearted and enjoyable adventure that could last you upward of 30 hours, depending on how quickly you decide to blow through the story. If you've been looking to light up the heavens with lasers and missiles, there's no reason you shouldn't forgive DarkStar One's flaws and take to the intergalactic trade lanes.
Andy Kelly
July 15, 2010 - Good - As it is, Darkstar One ultimately feels disappointingly limited, when it should be an epic voyage of discovery and adventure. But developers should take note: space sims do work on consoles… so let's have some more.
July 20, 2010 - Good - DarkStar One: Broken Alliance is big, complex, and just messy enough to make it hard to recommend without some reservation. If you've been hard up for a space combat sim, this is a lot of game for $50. If you're short on patience, though, you may want to sit this trip out.
Greg Howson
June 29, 2010 - Good - DarkStar One is a rough diamond. The amateurish voice-acting - complete with the most unplaceable range of accents ever - and low-grade cut scenes betray the game's aged development. Despite this, DarkStar One is recommended to patient Xbox 360 owners who fancy a game that involves something different to sniping or scoring.
Justin McElroy
July 22, 2010 - Good - In an alternate reality where top-tier studios were cranking out four or five of these sort of games a year, DSO's dated graphics and abysmal presentation would likely relegate it to an afterthought. But here on Earth Prime, where competent space shooters, especially on consoles, are bafflingly rare? I'm happy for whatever I can get.
Brian Dumlao
July 21, 2010 - Good - Even if it weren't the only game of its type on the console, it would be easy to recommend Broken Alliance as a purchase for anyone looking for a spaceship shooter with some depth. It's not the best surprise game of the summer, but it is an enjoyable one.
Anthony Gallegos
July 20, 2010 - Mediocre - DarkStar One: Broken Alliance has a lot to offer people who are easily entertained by doing the same things over and over, but for the rest of us what's offered here is a far too expensive version of a dated PC title.
Emmanuel Brown
July 19, 2010 - Mediocre - None of the single pieces of Darkstar are particularly shoddy (voicework aside), but mixed together they form an experience that's largely devoid of anything memorable, but also one that remains hypnotically sedate until eventual boredom sets in.
Ben Biggs
June 25, 2010 - Poor - At full price, Broken Alliance is heresy: it has a place on the 360, but repackaged as tribute to Elite and launched as an XBLA download at half the price.
User Comments
In order to add a comment, you must first create an account or log in.
Shop For This Game
DarkStar One: Broken Alliance
Purchase now for the Xbox 360
New & Upcoming Releases
Copyright © 2009-2010 Prime Element Creations. All Rights Reserved.
Prime Element Creations, the Prime Element Creations logo, ReviewTrax, and the ReviewTrax logo are all trademarks or registered trademarks of Prime Element Creations.
Quick Links
Network
Partners